Choosing the Right Website Hosting Platform: It’s Not One-Size-Fits-All
If you’ve ever listened to a podcast or watched a YouTube video about launching a business, you’ve probably heard names like Shopify and Squarespace dropped left and right. They’re practically everywhere.
That’s not by accident.
These platforms spend a lot of money on advertising—money that often comes from the small businesses using their services. But here’s the truth most marketers won’t tell you: Just because you’ve heard of a platform doesn’t mean it’s the right one for your business.
At Craft My Marketing (CMM), we’ve worked with a lot of different website builders. We don’t push one platform over another just because it’s easier for us. We guide you to the best choice for you. Your goals, your budget, your customers.
Let’s break it down.
Why Platform Choice Matters
Many businesses come to us facing the same SEO hurdles:
-
Low Search Rankings: Your website isn’t appearing where it should on Google.
-
Poor Website Traffic: You’re not getting enough visitors to your site.
-
Technical Issues: Slow load times, broken links, and mobile usability problems.
-
Weak Local SEO: Struggling to rank in local searches, missing out on nearby customers.
-
Keyword Confusion: Targeting the wrong keywords or not optimizing content effectively.
If any of these sound familiar, our SEO services can turn things around.
Popular Doesn't Always Mean Practical
Shopify
Shopify is the go-to for ecommerce—and for good reason. It’s powerful, secure, and great for selling physical products, especially if you want to:
-
Manage inventory
-
Handle shipping
-
Run discounts and sales
-
Integrate with point-of-sale (POS) systems
But here’s the catch: if you’re not running a store with a lot of products, Shopify can be overkill. You’ll pay monthly for features you might never use. Plus, their app ecosystem can get expensive fast.
Shopify is also a solid pick for subscription box businesses, thanks to its robust backend and automation tools. But even then, there are alternatives…
Subbly
Enter Subbly—a lesser-known but powerful option for subscription-based businesses. Subbly was built for subscription models and is:
-
Easier to set up than Shopify
-
More affordable for smaller businesses
-
Equipped with built-in tools for recurring payments, shipping, and emails
The trade-off? It’s not as scalable or customizable as Shopify. If you're planning to build the next FabFitFun or BarkBox, Shopify might still be the better bet. But for lean, community-driven boxes? Subbly’s a dream.
Squarespace
Squarespace gets a lot of buzz for its clean designs and drag-and-drop ease. It’s a good fit if you’re:
-
A creative with a portfolio (think photographers, artists, writers)
-
A small service-based business with simple needs
-
A blogger or personal brand with limited ecommerce
But Squarespace has limitations when it comes to:
-
Integrations
-
Custom functionality
-
Complex site structures
Also, many third-party tools don’t play nicely with Squarespace—so if you have niche requirements, it might not be your best choice.
WIX
WIX is one of our go-to platforms at CMM. It’s flexible, user-friendly, and constantly evolving. We love it for:
-
Local businesses
-
Restaurants
-
Personal brands
-
Service providers with basic booking needs
WIX offers great design flexibility and solid SEO tools right out of the box. But it’s not a silver bullet.
If you're a real estate agent, for example, embedding live listings from the MLS (Multiple Listing Service) can be a pain on WIX—or outright impossible—depending on your provider. That kind of integration usually needs a WordPress-based solution or something custom.
WordPress
WordPress is the chameleon of website platforms. It can be anything you want it to be—if you have the time, tech skills, or a developer.
Pros:
-
Incredibly flexible
-
Vast plugin library
-
Great for SEO
-
Scalable for any size
Cons:
-
Not beginner-friendly
-
You’re responsible for hosting, security, and maintenance
-
Can get expensive if you’re hiring help for every little thing
We typically recommend WordPress for clients with very specific needs—like real estate integrations, custom booking systems, or advanced functionality that no other platform can match.
Hostinger
Hostinger is a lesser-known but affordable option that we’ve come to love for certain clients. With its built-in site builder, it gives you:
-
A cleaner backend than WordPress
-
Lower monthly costs
-
Simple drag-and-drop editing
It’s a great fit for:
-
Budget-conscious startups
-
Brochure-style websites
-
Those who don’t need a lot of bells and whistles
However, if you outgrow it, migrating can be a challenge—so we always plan with the future in mind.
We Don't Sell You the "Best for Us." We Find the Best for You.
At Craft My Marketing, we don’t believe in a one-size-fits-all solution. We believe in custom-fit websites—because your business isn’t generic, and your website shouldn’t be either.
When you work with us, we:
✅ Listen to your goals and challenges
✅ Recommend the best-fit platform for your needs
✅ Handle the design, tech setup, SEO, and integrations
✅ Keep scalability and ease-of-use in mind
Whether you’re selling soap, teaching yoga, building a nonprofit, or launching a podcast—we’ll help you find the platform that fits like your favorite pair of jeans.
Final Thought: It's Okay Not to Know
We know it can feel overwhelming trying to choose the “right” platform when you don’t even know what you might need six months from now. That’s where we come in.
At CMM, we help you figure it out—before you commit. Because your business deserves a site that works for you, not just a shiny name you heard on a podcast.
Ready to talk about your dream site? Let’s find your perfect fit.